Where I Cram My Ideas


Sunday, July 15, 2007

Value-Laden Terms in Everyday Language

I don't usually listen to Nickelback where I can avoid it, but the lyrics of the song "Animals" caught my attention. The song is about sneaking out with a sexy girl and gettin' down without the parents being any the wiser. Chorus goes
No, we're never gonna quit
Ain't nothing wrong with it
Just acting like we're animals
Nobody reads this blog yet, but for those who might, you'll have noticed that I'm very concerned with how language is used. Consider the use of "it's just______." We hear that sort of phrase all of the time.

Concerning abortion, we hear "It's just a bunch of cells."
I hear Christians say "well, if evolution is true, then your mind is just a bunch of neurons firing."
In this song, the phrase is "Ain't nuthin' wrong with it, we're just a couple animals."

Value
These phrases are all the sort that describes a phenomenon with the intention of devaluing it. I don't care if the result of sperm+egg is 'just a bunch of cells.' Every living thing is 'just a bunch of cells.' However, the way our minds work, using this sort of phrase devalues the object of the conversation in the mind of the listener.

So what if the mind is 'just a bunch of neurons firing?' It's a fact, whether or not you believe in God, and that fact in no way diminishes the trustworthiness of our minds. When put in those terms, though, the speaker is trying to devalue the object.

Similarly, in the Nickelback song, the singer is trying to justify his actions by saying 'we're just a couple animals.' That's fine - in fact, it's completely true. We're all animals, though, and that fact has no bearing on right and wrong. However, the assumption in many human minds is that animals are of a lesser moral quality than humans, so if we're animals, then any action that an animal would perform is permissible. However, that is not the case. While it's true that many animals are much more civil towards members of their own species than humans are to our own, some animals eat their mates after copulating. Hopefully this is not a permissible thing for human beings to do.

It's false to say 'X is just ____, according to you, therefore your perspective is false.' That's obvious. Using that sort of unspoken line of reasoning, though, has a strong impact on the average listener, who may be of the sort of mindset where if a statement is unappealing, it is disregarded. It's best saved for another post, but people have to deal with reality - it is possible, if not common, for people to think 'I want there to be an afterlife. I didn't get a fair life, so there must be one,' and they'll believe it as if their belief makes any difference to reality. I may revisit this thought later.

A Further Example
One other example bears mentioning. On a Facebook discussion board this morning, I responded to an interesting claim. A young man made the perfectly valid claim that scientific claims can't exactly be proven beyond a shadow of a doubt. He then provided Webster's definition of faith (firm belief in something for which there is no proof). Since there is no proof for scientific claims, he said "There is evidence for evolution. There is no proof however. Thus, evolution (among some other things), like religion, must be taken on faith."

This is a pretty simple syllogism:
1. There is no proof for scientific theories
2. A belief without proof is faith.
3. Therefore, science, like religion, is based on faith.

Unfortunately, there is a little bit of a problem here. He presented 'proof' as certainty beyond a shadow of doubt. He pointed out that experiments exist that could disprove the Second Law of Thermodynamics, for instance. What he may not have realized is that experiments exist that could disprove nearly everything. For instance, nobody can prove 'beyond a shadow of doubt' that reality has existed for more than 5 minutes. In the sort of capacity he uses 'proof,' every single belief a person has is faith.

But that's not how faith is normally used, and it's not the impression that his words conveyed. Had he used the dictionary to understand the word, he would have found that 'proof' is defined thus: "evidence sufficient to establish a thing as true." For example, in our justice system, people are 'proven' guilty or innocent - beyond a reasonable doubt (scientific conclusions, likewise, are beyond a reasonable doubt).

So, is there a word to distinguish between the 'faith' that plants photosynthesize, and the 'faith' that there is an afterlife? Well, I'd like to think so. In fact, I'll call a propositional attitude regarding a statement a "belief," such an attitude based on solid evidence "sound belief" and such an attitude based on no such evidence (or in spite of evidence to the contrary) faith.

Using the word faith as this fellow did is a bad idea. I'm not sure he recognizes it yet, but when 'faith' is used to describe scientific theories, the automatic assumption is not the correct one - that 'faith' has been expanded to mean every single belief a human being has - the assumption is that scientific theories are not built on solid evidential foundations. This leads to similar devaluation by the average listener.

Many people think of 'rhetoric' to mean 'saying something without saying anything.' That's exactly what this person did - whether or not he recognized that, I'm not sure though, so I won't jump to that conclusion and condemn his actions.

Ultimately
The point to take away from all of this is that often a phenomenon is described in a way that casts it negatively, just to try to devalue a certain perspective. Don't fall for it. Question the motives of the speaker. If he is trying to deceive or confuse, he is worthy of moral condemnation.

PS I should mention that I'll use 'he' in most of my examples. Our language is regrettably lacking in the sort of terminology that would allow me to be gender-neutral in that sort of case (without being ponderous, anyway). I may switch and use 'she' every now and then just to throw the reader off :)

271 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 271 of 271
Anonymous said...

This may be where a regulated marketplace comes to rescue.
They offer within the support as very as assistance free help
over the phone.

My web blog ... grzejniki łazienkowe

Anonymous said...

If you now don't learn how and use the potty, then you must not go to preschool next month. Isolation exercises include single- joint and isometrics exercises.

my web site; grzejniki chromowane

Anonymous said...

This level of heat is required method to for plants
to develop. These provide relief to each body after taking the daily is working of routine.


Here is my blog - grzejniki chromowane

Anonymous said...

When it comes to translation of e-commerce websites,
prefer a person's translator.

My web site; grzejniki dekoracyjne

Anonymous said...

Is it Possible for watch Fox, NBC, CBS TV live online? Computer Winner
could remove or even improve those problems which.


my website :: grzejniki dekoracyjne

Anonymous said...

But new performance of these royalty free music it not. That music collection owned over the very long time represents your
traveling through life.

Look at my weblog - grzejniki łazienkowe

Anonymous said...

Another choice is to use sunshine to help to make domestic hot h2o within the house.
Need to always consider a few things when it appears
to installing those.

Feel free to surf to my web blog :: grzejniki chromowane

Anonymous said...

MOS certifications are also delivered for PowerPoint,
Word and Outlook. A little might be deemed to
be wholly potty trained, while still have no one can.



Here is my webpage; grzejniki łazienkowe

Anonymous said...

On this case, lodges and resorts remain most well-liked types.
No wonder why t-shirts are visible for the duration product launch other events.


Feel free to surf to my web site :: pomiary natężenia oświetlenia

Anonymous said...

Augment your creativity with the simple guides that application comes with.


my weblog :: szkolenia z pierwszej pomocy

Anonymous said...

The MAC compatibility means that the very Dub Turbo software can be are operated with
an iPad. Keeping updated with the latest trends is really a factor to
be looked into.

Also visit my blog post: ochrona przeciwpożarowa

Anonymous said...

Now, looking for virtually any reliable Lawyer providers
can be terrifying.

my homepage ... szkolenia ppoż

Anonymous said...

Click here to know more info on different t-shirt logo services on offer.

So depending on his or her industry we can get customized solutions likewise.


Review my site :: szkolenia ppoż

Anonymous said...

This is even more desirable in industrial wear T-shirts.
A vast assortment of t tshirts are designed and offered all around the world.


Also visit my web blog ... pomiary natężenia oświetlenia

Anonymous said...

This is what drink will assist in to restore sensory
problems function in your new colon and improve its health.
Large stools are easier provided they actually
are not hard.

Also visit my site - szkolenia bhp

Anonymous said...

Also the clients are marketed best quality in trade
of their price. The later is obviously the best choice.


Also visit my webpage; pomiary natężenia oświetlenia

Anonymous said...

Individual deductibles exercise separately to both equally covered person.
Walking gives you can the ability, additionally that a
decent thing for associated with us all.

Feel free to surf to my web blog: ochrona przeciwpożarowa

Anonymous said...

Augment your creativity with the simple guides that confidential details comes with.



Also visit my blog szkolenia ppoż

Anonymous said...

By removing rust formerly you stop loss in iron effectively.
Moreover, one dosen't posses to spend his or her own hard earned money on the business-related systems.

Also visit my blog: szkolenia z pierwszej pomocy

Anonymous said...

Unquestionably the rain-soaked soil flushed away and zero the walls for
her basement. Feel specific and realise the life style and design you love.



Stop by my web-site ... pomiary natężenia oświetlenia

Anonymous said...

Technique guide of the Mma training workouts take prescription the rise nowadays.

A program will continue being on course and prepare for a fight.



My website; ochrona przeciwpożarowa

Anonymous said...

Normally, basic a software application includes ample
quality to maintain any individual membership database.
A concern . Dub turbo several.0, the possibilities are endless.


my blog ... szkolenia ppoż

Anonymous said...

A profitable business would be inside a provide you a pretty good client-vendor
relationship.

my site badania termowizyjne

Anonymous said...

Exact training is something that is integral when you need to success in
an extensive majority of sports. It could choose to be any number reasons depending on
their own car.

Stop by my weblog - szkolenia z pierwszej pomocy

Anonymous said...

The later is also obviously the prime choice. Is actually it Possible
to watch Fox, NBC, CBS TV feed online?

Feel free to visit my page; minimalne wymagania maszyn

Anonymous said...

These bungalows give you a home good knowledge which makes data stay extremely pleasant.
Moreover, for accommodating at these homes, one need not
spend much.

Feel free to surf to my blog post; pomiary natężenia oświetlenia

Anonymous said...

In particular, the Translation India offers a clear view of target customers.


my webpage; pomiary natężenia oświetlenia

Anonymous said...

Execs can trace often the sewer traces properly. Isn't America a huge cesspool of crass commercialism and greedy, materialistic people?

Also visit my website - szkolenia bhp

Anonymous said...

Up to scratch mulch in your prized garden does a very lot
to cut down on the water use. Many of insecticides are strong,
including botanical kind.

Also visit my page; ochrona przeciwpożarowa

Anonymous said...

The role of a t-shirt may be very profound actually. With no your
own individual pattern, you could use images provided in the
web site.

My website - szkolenia bhp

Anonymous said...

Due to which reason, real property in India is one
among the the biggest prosperous sectors. In the islands, various sized holiday
rental homes are usable.

Also visit my site: szkolenia bhp

Anonymous said...

Vivaldi himself previously had fallen into obscurity by the give up
of his life time. People from around the world come over to enjoy this amazing divine show.



Look into my homepage pomiary natężenia oświetlenia

Anonymous said...

For this reason, professional translation producers are now into great demand.

Moreover, it has centralized repository that websites past
translations.

my web page - ochrona przeciwpożarowa

Anonymous said...

Ask for a registrations at numerous trade groups. Apparatus making itself displays evolved into one particular much more tricky process.


Also visit my page - szkolenia z pierwszej pomocy

Anonymous said...

Property market is having to deal with better monetary maturity than any other sectors.


Feel free to surf to my web blog badania termowizyjne

Anonymous said...

The strength of this captivating voice based service lies in
nulled program. Whatever your intention is, you'll want to focus on type of aspects of your small business activity. It should not at all be either big or too thinning. Only that must canrrrt you create been unionized teaching labor. http://www.no-ops.org/groups/the-stress-and-its-effect-working-people-out-of-call-center/

Anonymous said...

They need not prove retained for up to a long time of age.
They wander via the crowds while using handfuls of metal tools
that they use.

Have a look at my web page gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Every single business owner is very much interested in original advertising models and ways accomplish more exposure.
Once the plan is wearing place, promote it.

Here is my blog; gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Steve, in January had alleged that Siri is not execution to its worry level.
Buzz up; just coastal cottage decor your idea
for the fashion war. Both look good, but the look you choose would certainly depend on frame, height and manner style.
Clip them to a establish card or on the whole ribbon and build across each dish.
http://www.yzxshm.com/component/option,com_phocaguestbook/Itemid,6/id,
1/view,phocaguestbook/index.php?do=basic

Feel free to visit my blog post party dresses

Anonymous said...

Following they are with no longer properly working, they must nevertheless be uninstalled.

And all of such a overheads only pennies on the real money!


Also visit my web-site ... gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Expensive jewelry are highly transparent, graphite completely opaque and the shortlist goes on.



Here is my web site; gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

It is advisable to have analysts do the availability. They covers
that are put over the surface of your hot bath tub when
it is not in use.

Feel free to visit my blog - gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

It is used to tote out all functionings according to all need.
Because author knows, you can find a mechanical element
to writing, and a creative aspect.

Feel free to visit my website - gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

These happenings show up at life to make various purposes.
You have to create a venue the has enough room in
your home for that strip to carry out there.

my homepage :: gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Doesn't Title IX simply prohibit discrimination based on sexual intimacy? Additionally, we would both be sincerely interested in working towards comparable thing cause.

My site - gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

We all use the keyword phrase easy as a relative term.

In the pictures from the basement you can understand daylight through the actual cinder
blocks.

my page ... gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Even Universities require you to work as a alumni or
reimbursement for information. Accumulated natural gas in
tanks does be hazardous.

Here is my web-site - gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

All you are looking for to do is look for those same indications.
This provides a common ground with regard to to meet and share important circumstances that may effect their valuable life.


Also visit my blog - gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Pores of the skin open and as a result release sweat which is also good for
the health of the skin. The prices will vary end result of the company signing up the plan.



my weblog gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

SEO services provided by Jigney Bhachech, CEO Opal Infotech, India.
Keeping close to a new coast means seashore breezes can
offset some of heat.

Feel free to surf to my web blog :: gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Indian music has some elements - 'Raag' and 'Taal'.
The important thing to earning money with your own music is
to initial produce a wonderfully done master Bank cd.



My web page gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

In which applies to many attorneys you take a look at
on TV. The latest very good cases of divorce lawyer will make it easier for you
to run emotionally charged stability.

my weblog ... gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

The city has a population of around 5.3 million and has strong
connections to assist you NRIs.

Feel free to visit my web blog - http://socjologiaiurbanistyka.
com.pl/ ()

Anonymous said...

The adjuster's do the job will depend the least chunk paid to the claimer.

my site ... gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Do you need someone to help you secure custody of your kids?
This may finish result in more low monthly mortgage finance payments for you.


Here is my webpage; gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Ask them to provide you with client recommendations and what techniques they use.
If you're a neighborhood organization, We've beneficial news for
you. Properly, right here are some factors you should
examine just before your select an ideal search engine optimization provider for the on-line advertising and marketing.


Feel free to surf to my site: high qualty PR backlinks gigs

Anonymous said...

Method always avoid dark at all bargains when planning a complete kid friendly refreshments.
Still, always be many to provide therapy to your kid.


my webpage ... gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

All together private, totally exclusive, uniquely beautiful all?
Such areas command a very high price structure when compared rest of
town.

Here is my website: gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Keep the bottle filled with beer, up to all about an inch beyond the top.
So, know what do you really need to do think about when buying a health insurance police?


Feel free to surf to my homepage; gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Avoidance is better when compared cure - so goes the
explaining. Tools that are almost always coated have an actual 'self-cleaning' property.


My webpage - gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Finish your backyard garden clean-up before weather gets too nasty.
For burned concerning residue, use our cleaner recommended by the manufacturer.


Check out my blog post: gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

Money-making niches some great product or service books and you should read them.
Involved with course, I attain have far a reduced amount
of experience and feats than Mr Frawley.

Feel free to surf to my weblog :: gsa search engine ranker

Anonymous said...

There are a few prominent players previously British Designer Fashion Industry.
Learn about numerous effective ways enhance survey participation.
Conduct a new great online satisfaction survey. The results of your research will end worth the along with effort spent into it.
http://holsteiner-arschloch.de/wiki/index.php?title=Benutzer:SherlynAb

Visit my blog; men's paul smith shoes

Anonymous said...

She ruled that these forms of tickets violate the specific driver's right to assist you to due process.

Also visit my website ... pozycjonowanie

Anonymous said...

The important thing to earning money using your own music is to initial produce a magnificently done master Dvd.
Australia has country legends like Slim Dirty and James Blundell.


my homepage ... pozycjonowanie

Anonymous said...

Most companies make full use of printed T-shirt to be market their manufacturers.
There are quite a few companies, which give you a
quality help at an reasonably-priced price.

Look into my page - pozycjonowanie

Anonymous said...

Hasten t-shirt services even offers custom embroidery professional
services. This is certainly why it are important to moderate comments continually.


Also visit my web-site; pozycjonowanie

Anonymous said...

They will execute everything that they can for which unfortunately to happen.
Come across is another you simply ought to within mind mind while hiring a lawyer.



Also visit my web-site: pozycjonowanie

Anonymous said...

These days economical and law areas of expertise are the largest ones.
There is, for example, a vocation of cesspool more refined - who in order to be the you?



my web-site :: pozycjonowanie

Anonymous said...

Untrained people can possibly damage the equipment or
cistern. An area using a bottom where the particular
cesspool sits below may be raised or depressed.

Check out my web page - pozycjonowanie

Anonymous said...

My - SQL database makes it easy to store Wordpress blog
information, as well as export aand backup My - SQL database.
Kelly's sexiness comes from the almost effortless way she pulls
it off without looking like she's trying to be. This new method is the
compression type of 7-Zip, an open source archiving format for users of nearly any operating
system.

Look into my page; cracker mot de passe rar

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 271 of 271   Newer› Newest»